Your situation
How to Sell an Underwater House: Your Options When You Owe More Than It's Worth
Updated 9 min read7 cited sources
Short answer
To sell a house when you owe more than it is worth, you either bring cash to closing to cover the gap or ask your lender to approve a short sale for less than you owe. Other options are a loan modification, a deed in lieu of foreclosure, renting the house out, or waiting for prices to rise. A cash buyer cannot pay more than the house is worth.
Key takeaways
- You are underwater when your loan payoff plus selling costs is more than the house would realistically sell for.
- A buyer, cash or not, only pays what the house is worth. Someone has to cover the gap: you, or your lender through a short sale.
- In some states a lender can come after you for the leftover balance after a short sale. Ask for a written deficiency waiver.
- IRS Publication 4681 says the main-home exclusion for forgiven mortgage debt does not apply to discharges after December 31, 2025. Talk to a tax pro.
- A free HUD-approved housing counselor can help you compare options before you sign anything.
What does it mean to be underwater on a house?
You are underwater, also called having negative equity, when you owe more on your mortgage than the house is worth. If you sold today, the sale price would not be enough to pay off your loan.
For selling, the number that matters is a little bigger than your loan balance. You also have to pay closing costs and, if you list, agent commissions. So a house can be "slightly above water" on paper and still leave you short at closing.
You are not alone. In ATTOM's Q2 2026 Home Equity and Underwater Report, 3.2 percent of U.S. mortgaged homes were seriously underwater, meaning the owner owed at least 25 percent more than the estimated market value. That was up from 2.7 percent a year earlier. Minnesota (12.1 percent) and Louisiana (10.3 percent) had the highest rates.
How do you check if you are underwater?
Compare your payoff amount with a realistic sale price, then subtract selling costs. If the result is negative, you are underwater for selling purposes.
- Get a written payoff quote from your servicer. This is not the balance on your statement. It includes interest to the payoff date and any fees.
- Add every loan on the house. Include home equity loans, HELOCs, and any liens. All of them get paid at closing.
- Find a realistic price. Look at recent sales of similar homes nearby, in similar condition. Online estimates are a starting point, not a price. An agent's market analysis or an appraisal is better.
- Subtract selling costs. Closing costs, plus agent commission if you list, plus any repairs a buyer will ask for.
Example: your payoff is $250,000. Similar homes in your condition sell for about $240,000. Selling costs would be about $20,000. You would need to bring roughly $30,000 to closing ($250,000 + $20,000 − $240,000 = $30,000 short).
Our cash offer calculator can help you compare what you might net from an investor offer versus listing.
Can a cash buyer help if you owe more than the house is worth?
Usually not on its own. A cash investor cannot pay more than the house is worth, and most pay less than full retail value because they cover repairs, holding costs, and resale risk.
Investors often use a rule of thumb of about 70 percent of after-repair value minus repairs. That is an industry rule of thumb, not a law or a statistic, and offers vary. See how cash home buyers calculate offers for the details.
So if you are underwater, a cash sale usually still needs one of two things: your lender approving a short sale, or cash from you to cover the gap. Anyone who promises to "make your mortgage go away" without either of those deserves hard questions.
Where a cash buyer can help is speed and condition. If the house needs work and your lender approves a short sale, a buyer who takes it as-is and can close quickly may make the lender's approval easier. Cash Offer Desk, for example, gives a written as-is offer in the areas where it buys and tells you up front, in writing, if it plans to assign the contract to an investor partner. On an underwater house, that offer still has to be accepted by your lender.
What are your options when you owe more than the house is worth?
You have six main options. Which one fits depends on whether you need to move, whether you can afford the payment, and how far underwater you are.
| Option | Keep the house? | What it means | Main risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bring cash to closing | No | Sell normally and pay the shortfall yourself | You need the cash |
| Short sale | No | Lender agrees to accept less than you owe (CFPB) | Deficiency, taxes, credit damage, slow approval |
| Loan modification | Yes | Servicer changes your loan terms to lower the payment (CFPB key terms) | Still underwater; not everyone qualifies |
| Deed in lieu | No | You give the house back to the lender instead of foreclosure (CFPB) | Deficiency, taxes, credit damage |
| Rent it out | Yes | Tenants help cover the payment while you wait | Vacancies, repairs, being a landlord |
| Wait | Yes | Keep paying until the loan balance drops or prices rise | Prices may not rise; your life may not wait |
Bring cash to closing
If the gap is small and you have savings, this is the cleanest option. You sell like anyone else, the title company pays off your loan, and you cover the difference. There is no lender approval, no forgiven debt, and no hit to your credit from the sale itself.
Short sale
A short sale is a sale for less than you owe, with your lender's or servicer's approval (CFPB). You find a buyer, the lender reviews your hardship and the offer, and if it agrees, it accepts the sale price as payment.
Three things to know before you start:
- Deficiency risk varies by state. In some states the lender can sue you for the leftover balance after a short sale. The CFPB says to ask your lender to waive the deficiency and get that waiver in writing. Check your state at /sell-my-house-for-cash and ask a real estate attorney.
- Forgiven debt may be taxable. See the tax section below.
- It takes time. The lender sets its own paperwork list and review pace. Sellers with a foreclosure date should read selling a house facing foreclosure too.
Loan modification
If you want to stay and the problem is the payment, ask your servicer about a modification. It changes the loan terms, often to lower the monthly payment. It does not fix negative equity, but it can keep you in the house while values and your balance move in your favor.
Deed in lieu of foreclosure
With a deed in lieu, you sign the house back to the lender and walk away. The CFPB says to get any deficiency waiver in writing, notes you may still owe taxes, and says some lenders offer moving money, sometimes called "cash for keys." Loan owners like Fannie Mae list their own non-retention options, so ask what your loan owner allows.
Rent it out
If the rent you can get covers most of your payment, taxes, and insurance, renting can buy time. It also makes you a landlord, with repairs, vacancies, and tenant laws. Check your loan terms and insurance before you move out. If you later sell with a tenant in place, see selling a house with tenants.
Wait
Every payment lowers your balance a little, and prices may rise. But they may also fall, and waiting only works if you can keep paying. If a job loss, divorce, or move is forcing the issue, waiting may not be realistic.
Is forgiven mortgage debt taxable in 2026?
It can be. When a lender forgives part of what you owe in a short sale, deed in lieu, or foreclosure, the forgiven amount can count as income unless an exclusion applies.
For years, many homeowners used the qualified principal residence exclusion for forgiven debt on a main home. IRS Publication 4681 (for 2025 returns) says that exclusion cannot be used for discharges completed, or discharge agreements entered into, after December 31, 2025. Tax rules can change, so check the current version of Publication 4681 or ask a tax pro whether that has changed.
Other rules may still help. Publication 4681 explains the insolvency exclusion, which can apply if your debts were more than your assets right before the debt was canceled. It also explains that if your lender cancels debt, you may get Form 1099-C. How these rules apply depends on your loan type, your state, and your finances. This is not tax advice. Talk to a tax professional before you agree to a short sale or deed in lieu.
Who should you talk to before you decide?
Start with a free HUD-approved housing counselor, then your servicer, then an attorney or tax pro for the details. Counselors work for you, not the lender, and do not charge for foreclosure help.
You can find one through HUD's housing counseling page or by calling 800-569-4287. Bring:
- Your payoff quote and statements for every loan on the house.
- Your best estimate of the home's value, with recent nearby sales.
- Proof of income and a list of monthly expenses.
- Any letters from your servicer, especially anything about missed payments.
Then talk to a real estate attorney about deficiency rules in your state, and a tax pro about forgiven debt. Never pay anyone up front to "negotiate" with your lender, and never sign your deed over outside a real closing. Our guide on spotting cash home buyer scams covers the warning signs.
What if you have a reverse mortgage instead?
Reverse mortgages work differently. The balance grows over time, and the rules for selling or handing the house back are not the same as a regular mortgage. Read selling a house with a reverse mortgage before you use anything on this page.
When does selling to a cash buyer make sense on an underwater house?
It makes sense when your lender has approved, or is open to, a short sale, and the house needs repairs that would scare off buyers using loans. It can also make sense if you are only slightly underwater and are willing to bring cash, because a fast as-is sale cuts holding costs.
It usually does not make sense if the house is in good shape and the market is decent. A listing with an agent will likely bring a higher price, which means a smaller gap for you or your lender to cover. Compare both in cash offer vs listing with an agent.
Get more than one offer, and have an attorney review any contract, including ours. If you want to see what an as-is cash offer looks like, read how it works or request an offer.
Common questions
Can I sell my house if I have no equity?
Can a cash home buyer pay off my whole mortgage if I am underwater?
Does a short sale hurt my credit?
Do I have to pay taxes on a short sale?
How long does a short sale take?
Sources
- 1.ATTOM: Q2 2026 U.S. Home Equity and Underwater Report
- 2.CFPB: What is a short sale?
- 3.CFPB: What is a deed-in-lieu of foreclosure?
- 4.CFPB: Mortgage key terms
- 5.IRS Publication 4681: Canceled debts, foreclosures, repossessions, and abandonments
- 6.HUD: Housing counseling
- 7.Fannie Mae: Non-retention options
This guide is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Laws and company policies change; check the sources and talk to a local real estate attorney or tax professional about your situation.